Top Toasters by Consumer Reviewers

Toasters can be considered as one of the most versatile kitchen appliances. In addition to toasting bread, it also enables you to heat pizza and other food items. Most toasters today are loaded with extra features and are even capable of convection baking thus, adding a real level of functionality to the product. Some also have a backlit LCD screen along with digital controls and a built in memory which eliminates the need to enter your preferred settings each time you'll use the toaster. Here at IntelliReview, we make it easier to find the perfect toaster for your home. After looking at many different websites, we compiled a list of the top toasters you should know about. We call this unique process consumer passion as it allows us to offer you only the best models based on both positive and negative reviews given by consumers. So whether you want to toast two slices at once or have a larger, more complete toaster oven with a timer, browsing below is an excellent idea. Our unique and useful method of identifying high quality toasters can save you both time and money. Instead of browsing through countless reviews on your own, look at the review of the best toasters below and make your decision easier.

Ranking Updated: August 2016
TIPS
  1. Simple bread toasters can be enough if all you need is toasted bread, but for added versatility, it's recommended that you own a toaster oven as well, since it adds more functionality.
  2. Manual browning control options let you cook a piece of bread just the way you want it, while a bread slot allows you to raise the bread higher so that getting it is safer.
  3. Most toasters are made for loaves of bread, but some are specially designed for thick breads, like bagels and English muffins.
  4. Look for features like crumb trays and insulated handles for safety purposes.
  • BOV800XL Smart 6-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster Oven

    BOV800XL Smart 6-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster Oven

    3368 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Most popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $249.95  See It

    Pros: Cooks evenly, Intuitive controls, Easy to clean, Quiet
    Cons: No interior light, Expensive, Hot exterior

    Review: The Breville BOV800XL simplifies cooking with its Element IQ which calculates the ideal time and temperature and 9 pre-set functions consisting of Roast, Bake, Toast, Broil, Reheat, Warm, Pizza, Bagel and Cookies. It has a defrost button for thawing meat and other frozen food and features an Auto-Rack Eject which eliminates the risk of burning your hand. Given its size, this 1800 watt convection oven can hold up to six bread slices or up to 13" pizza. It heats up quickly and delivers greater results than most ovens. In terms of construction, it is built with stainless steel for maximum durability and a glass door which allows you to take a quick look at your food. Its Pull-Out Crumb Tray provides a no-fuss cleanup while its backlit LCD makes it easy to operate and view from across the room. Its controls are also very intuitive. It has a function dial, a time dial and a temperature knob that permit easy adjustment. Along with the oven, you also get a 12" X 12" enamel baking pan, a 12" X 12" enamel broil rack and a 13" non-stick pizza pan. However, just like any other unit, Breville's BOV800XL does have its drawbacks. It has no interior light, for example, and its outer surface tends to get hot. Its price is also a little higher but overall, its wide functionality and quiet operation make it a worthy upgrade for your average oven.

  • Classic Toaster Oven Broiler

    Classic Toaster Oven Broiler

    2379 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Most popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $69.77  See It
  • TSSTTVMNDG Digital Large Capacity Toaster Oven

    TSSTTVMNDG Digital Large Capacity Toaster Oven

    1317 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Most popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $79.99  See It
  • Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster

    Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster

    1108 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Most popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $74.15  See It

    Pros: Reliable, Easy to use, Backlit LCD display, Nice design
    Cons: Expensive, Slots could be deeper

    Review: The Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster works in a completely different way than most basic, traditional toasters. It has 7 shade settings that make your bagels, frozen waffles, english muffins and other bread crisp yet tender inside. The adjustable temperature enables you to easily get your desired crustiness and avoid burnt food. Although you can toast English muffins using the highest setting, you might need to put it in the toaster twice to get the desired results. The slots are also not deep and wide enough so toasting longer and thicker types of bread can be more time-consuming, as you need to flip them over in order to toast both sides. With its blue backlit LCD display, the Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster remains easy to use, regardless if it’s morning, noon or night. It even has a countdown timer and reheat, defrost and bagel functions for one-touch operation. Dual control panels and backlit displays can be found on the 4-slice version. Since there is no lever, the bread is automatically lowered into the unit. It also pops out automatically and you’ll hear a loud beep once the toasting cycle is complete. The leverless design means that you can’t manually raise the bread to a higher level, requiring you to use a fork to be able to reach and get smaller types of bread. The Cuisinart CPT-420 and CPT-440 can accommodate two slices and four slices of bread, respectively. Its stainless steel housing matches most kitchen appliances and makes it easy to wipe clean. All in all, it might be expensive but its reliability, design and features easily justify the extra cost.

  • Touch to Toast Leverless 2 SliceToaster

    Touch to Toast Leverless 2 SliceToaster

    1108 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Most popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $75.51  See It

    Pros: Reliable, Easy to use, Backlit LCD display, Nice design
    Cons: Expensive, Slots could be deeper

    Review: The Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster works in a completely different way than most basic, traditional toasters. It has 7 shade settings that make your bagels, frozen waffles, english muffins and other bread crisp yet tender inside. The adjustable temperature enables you to easily get your desired crustiness and avoid burnt food. Although you can toast English muffins using the highest setting, you might need to put it in the toaster twice to get the desired results. The slots are also not deep and wide enough so toasting longer and thicker types of bread can be more time-consuming, as you need to flip them over in order to toast both sides. With its blue backlit LCD display, the Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster remains easy to use, regardless if it’s morning, noon or night. It even has a countdown timer and reheat, defrost and bagel functions for one-touch operation. Dual control panels and backlit displays can be found on the 4-slice version. Since there is no lever, the bread is automatically lowered into the unit. It also pops out automatically and you’ll hear a loud beep once the toasting cycle is complete. The leverless design means that you can’t manually raise the bread to a higher level, requiring you to use a fork to be able to reach and get smaller types of bread. The Cuisinart CPT-420 and CPT-440 can accommodate two slices and four slices of bread, respectively. Its stainless steel housing matches most kitchen appliances and makes it easy to wipe clean. All in all, it might be expensive but its reliability, design and features easily justify the extra cost.

  • Board 4 Slctoaster Wide4slotssblk TR1400SB

    Board 4 Slctoaster Wide4slotssblk TR1400SB

    1459 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Most popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $38.39  See It
  • 2-Slice Compact Toaster White

    2-Slice Compact Toaster White

    1441 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Most popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $25.76  See It
  • TR1200SB 2-Slice Toaster, 1 ea

    TR1200SB 2-Slice Toaster, 1 ea

    1430 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Very popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $29.99  See It
  • BOV650XL The Compact Smart Toaster Oven

    BOV650XL The Compact Smart Toaster Oven

    1035 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Most popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $179.00  See It

    Pros: Well-made trays, Easy to read panel, Heats up quickly
    Cons: Tray does not slide out, Pricey

    Review: The Breville BOV650XL is a countertop appliance that adds sparkle to your kitchen and offers a wide array of functionalities that can't be found on a typical toaster. It is very powerful, with a size that makes it possible to cook a large quantity of food. All you need to do is to select from the eight preset functions: toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, and reheat then its Element IQ "smart" sensor will take care of the rest. It also allows you to manually adjust the cooking time from one minute up to two hours and set your preferred temperature from 120 to 450 degrees F. The backlit control panel on the Breville Smart Oven has large numbers which makes it easy to read even across the room. It changes its color from orange to blue to indicate when it's cooking and when it's done. Other highlights include three rack positions, a removable crumb tray that provides no-fuss cleaning and additional functions like start/cancel, defrost and temperature conversion. The only concern is that its tray does not automatically slide out so you have to be careful when getting the food but unlike other toasters, the cooking pans and racks that come with it do not look flimsy and cheap. The 10-by-10-inch enamel baking pan and 10-by-10-inch enamel broil rack are well constructed and should last a long time if properly taken care of. Bottom line, if you are in the market for a fine looking kitchen equipment and are willing to spend more for quality then this 1800-watt Compact Smart Oven is one of the best options.

  • CPT-160 Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster

    CPT-160 Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster

    1025 Reviews

    Consumer Passion : Most passionate
    Popularity : Most popular
    Amazon.com  Price: $41.09  See It